Why Behavioral Health Needs an Offensive RCM Strategy
John Peloquin went 20 years without a payer contract dispute, then filed four in 18 months. What changed, and what it means for behavioral health RCM teams.
In this article
- The shift from passive claims follow-up to an offensive RCM strategy
- Timely filing limits are not the same as payment deadlines
- In-network versus out-of-network: The leverage gap
- Why payers are scrutinizing behavioral health claims more closely
- Rising deductibles add another layer of financial pressure
- How behavioral health became more institutionalized
- D365: Supporting patients beyond discharge
- "One healthcare lane": Behavioral health belongs in the broader healthcare system
- Denovo or acquisition? Start with the mission, not the exit strategy
- What behavioral health operators should take away
- Listen to Episode 3 of The Cycle
For years, many behavioral health providers could rely on established payer relationships to resolve claims and payment issues. That approach is becoming harder to sustain.
John Peloquin spent almost 25 years in eating disorders, mental health and addiction, including as CEO of Discovery Behavioral Health. He is now founder and CEO of Right Path Recovery, part of Integrated Behavioral Health Group. He started out in methadone treatment, back when, as he puts it, "MAT was a bad word."
His advice to operators is direct: stop waiting for payer issues to resolve themselves. Build an offensive RCM strategy.
In Episode 3 of The Cycle, Supa's podcast with the operators building behavioral health, John tells host Samyukktha Thirumeni how payer behavior has changed, why providers need to exercise their contractual rights, and how the industry has evolved through consolidation and greater attention to clinical quality.
Watch the episode: Behavioral health deserves better, with John Peloquin
His conversation offers practical lessons for behavioral health founders, operators, and revenue cycle leaders navigating an increasingly demanding reimbursement environment.
The shift from passive claims follow-up to an offensive RCM strategy
One of the clearest signals of how payer-provider relationships have changed comes from John's own experience.
He says he filed no payer contract disputes in more than 20 years of his career. In the 18 months before the conversation, he had filed four.
That change captures his central point: providers can no longer assume that contractual payment obligations will be met without consistent follow-up and, when necessary, formal escalation.
John describes the earlier environment as more "collegial." Today, he believes providers need to be more deliberate about enforcing the terms of their payer agreements.
For an RCM team, this means the job does not end when a claim is submitted or when a payment is delayed. Teams need a process for identifying when a payer has missed a contractual obligation and taking action.
"You need an offensive RCM strategy."
The practical implication is straightforward: know what your payer contracts promise, track whether those promises are being met, and act when they are not.
Timely filing limits are not the same as payment deadlines
One of John's most useful operational examples concerns payment timelines.
He describes contracts that guarantee payment within 45–60 days. His recommendation is to begin systematic follow-up as soon as the applicable contractual deadline passes.
For example:
- If the contract requires payment within 45 days, begin follow-up on day 46.
- If the contract allows 60 days, begin follow-up on day 61.
This is not the same as a timely filing limit.
A timely filing limit generally determines how long a provider has to submit a claim after a service is delivered. A contractual payment deadline concerns how long a payer has to process and pay a properly submitted claim. Missing the first produces a denial you cannot appeal; missing the second is the payer's problem, and the point of John's argument is that someone has to make it theirs.
Confusing the two can create serious workflow problems. A claim may be submitted within the timely filing window but remain unpaid beyond the payer's contractual processing period.
For behavioral health billing teams, both deadlines need to be tracked.
Build a payment follow-up process around the contract
A practical workflow should include:
| Step | What the RCM team should do |
|---|---|
| 1. Review the contract | Identify payment terms and applicable claim-processing timelines |
| 2. Record submission dates | Maintain a reliable record of when clean claims were submitted |
| 3. Track claim status | Monitor acknowledgments, adjudication, and payment on the remittance |
| 4. Flag overdue claims | Identify claims that have passed the contractual payment deadline, and watch days in A/R by payer rather than in aggregate |
| 5. Follow up systematically | Contact the payer and document the response |
| 6. Escalate unresolved issues | Use the contract's dispute and escalation processes when appropriate |
The exact deadline and remedy depend on the agreement. A 45-day or 60-day term should not be assumed to apply to every payer or every claim.
The important lesson is to make the contract operational. Payment terms should influence the team's daily work, not sit unread in a document folder.
In-network versus out-of-network: The leverage gap
John also highlights a structural difference between in-network and out-of-network providers.
In-network providers have a contractual relationship with the payer. That agreement can provide a basis for challenging missed payment obligations and using formal dispute mechanisms.
Out-of-network providers do not have the same contractual leverage. When payment disagreements arise, their options may be more limited, and litigation can be expensive.
This does not mean every in-network dispute will be resolved in the provider's favor, or that out-of-network providers have no legal remedies. It does mean the available routes can be materially different.
For operators deciding whether to participate in a payer network, reimbursement rates are only one part of the decision. In-network vs. out-of-network covers the rest of that trade-off.
They should also consider:
- Contractual payment terms
- Claims and appeal procedures
- Medical-necessity and authorization requirements
- Recoupment and audit provisions
- Dispute-resolution mechanisms
- The administrative cost of maintaining the relationship
Network participation is a business decision with operational consequences. Providers need to understand not only what they will be paid, but also what rights and obligations come with the agreement.
Why payers are scrutinizing behavioral health claims more closely
John offers an explanation for the changing payer environment.
He recalls a conversation with a payer-side executive who said behavioral health spending at her organization had increased from approximately 2% to 9% of total spend.
John connects this growth in spending with increased scrutiny of behavioral health claims.
He also uses the term "worried well" to describe lower-acuity populations that payers may be trying to triage out of higher-cost treatment settings.
The point is not that every payer is applying the same strategy or that increased spending automatically justifies denying care. Rather, behavioral health operators should recognize that the sector's growing share of healthcare spending is changing the level of attention payers give to utilization, medical necessity, and reimbursement.
For providers, this makes documentation and utilization review even more important.
A strong clinical record should support the services delivered, the patient's needs, the treatment plan, and the rationale for continued care. How MSE documentation determines medical necessity works through what a reviewer actually looks for. RCM teams need workflows that identify documentation gaps before they become avoidable payment problems.
Rising deductibles add another layer of financial pressure
John also points to rising consumer deductibles, citing ranges of approximately $5,000 to $25,000.
High deductibles can complicate collections even when a claim is processed correctly. Patients may be responsible for substantial amounts before their insurance begins contributing meaningfully to covered services.
This creates a challenge for behavioral health organizations: the payer relationship is only one part of the revenue cycle. Patient responsibility can also affect collections, cash flow, and the ability to sustain services.
Operators should pay attention to:
- Eligibility and benefit verification before services begin
- Clear communication about estimated patient responsibility
- Collection policies that are consistent and appropriately applied
- Payment-plan processes where available
- Accurate statements and follow-up
- Good Faith Estimate obligations where applicable
The financial experience of the patient is part of the operating model. Unexpected costs can damage trust and make it harder for patients to continue care.
How behavioral health became more institutionalized
While John's RCM advice is the most immediate operational takeaway, his broader view of the industry helps explain why the environment has changed.
He describes earlier behavioral health operations as the "wild wild west." Facilities could market themselves around amenities such as an ocean view, a farm view, or access to horses, rather than demonstrating measurable quality and outcomes.
John believes private equity and institutional investment helped push the industry toward greater operational rigor.
Although private equity has attracted criticism across healthcare, he argues that consolidation brought more attention to quality, systems, and accountability at scaled organizations.
His point is not that consolidation automatically improves care. It is that the industry has moved toward greater expectations around how treatment organizations operate and demonstrate value.
Two major developments also helped bring behavioral health into the mainstream: the opioid epidemic and COVID-19.
Both made mental health and addiction treatment harder to ignore. They brought greater public attention to conditions that had often been stigmatized or treated as separate from the rest of healthcare.
D365: Supporting patients beyond discharge
John's experience also includes building D365, a post-discharge support tool during his time at Discovery Behavioral Health.
The concept addressed a recurring challenge in treatment: patients leave a structured care environment and return to the circumstances in which their difficulties developed.
A discharge plan is important, but recovery and mental health management do not stop when a patient leaves a facility.
D365 was designed as a 12-month post-discharge support tool. It used mobile check-ins and included an AI-driven facial-analysis component intended to identify signs of distress and support earlier intervention.
John reported that the program was associated with materially lower relapse rates. The conversation does not provide a quantified effect size, so the result should be understood as his account of the program rather than an independently established outcome.
He also describes applying this longer-term approach to eating disorders and mental health, treating these conditions as chronic rather than episodic.
The broader operational lesson is that treatment organizations should think beyond the length of an admission. Continuity, follow-up, and the transition back into everyday life can all influence what happens after discharge.
"One healthcare lane": Behavioral health belongs in the broader healthcare system
John has a personal framework for how behavioral health should be treated: "one healthcare lane."
He describes the phrase as a long-standing idea, represented even by a physical street sign in his office reception area.
The principle is that behavioral health should operate with the same rigor, integration, and dignity as physical healthcare. It should not be treated as a stigmatized parallel system.
This has implications beyond clinical care.
Integration means behavioral health organizations need strong clinical standards, reliable operational systems, responsible data practices, and financial processes that can support long-term care.
It also means patients should not have to navigate an unnecessarily fragmented experience simply because their needs involve mental health or substance use.
John's framework is ultimately about bringing behavioral health into the broader healthcare conversation, rather than treating it as a separate category.
Denovo or acquisition? Start with the mission, not the exit strategy
John also discusses the choice between building a behavioral health business from scratch and acquiring an existing operation.
He does not frame it as a simple either-or decision.
Instead, he argues that founders should start with a clear mission and a defined niche. The decision to build or buy should follow from the kind of organization they want to create.
This is a useful counterpoint to growth strategies built primarily around acquiring EBITDA and selling the business later.
For a new entrant, the questions should come first:
- Which patient population do you intend to serve?
- What level of care can you deliver well?
- What clinical philosophy will guide the organization?
- Is there a genuine need for the services in your target market?
- What capabilities will you need to deliver consistent care?
- Does an acquisition help you achieve that mission, or would building from scratch give you better control?
John also notes that patients are becoming more discerning. He recalls patients asking facilities for their PHQ-9 scores, reflecting a greater interest in measurable information about their care.
That is a meaningful shift. Patients are not only comparing amenities or convenience. They increasingly want to understand how their care is assessed and whether the organization can explain its approach.
For providers, quality and trust are not just marketing messages. They need to be reflected in the care delivered and the information shared with patients.
What behavioral health operators should take away
John's conversation brings together several changes affecting behavioral health organizations. The most practical lessons are:
1. Treat payer contracts as operating documents. Know the payment terms, dispute provisions, and obligations that apply to each payer. Build them into daily RCM workflows.
2. Follow up when contractual deadlines pass. Do not wait indefinitely for overdue claims to resolve. Use systematic follow-up and documented escalation.
3. Understand the difference between in-network and out-of-network leverage. The contractual rights and practical dispute options available to providers can differ significantly.
4. Prepare for greater payer scrutiny. As behavioral health spending receives more attention, strong documentation, utilization review, and medical-necessity support become increasingly important. Denial rates have been climbing across the sector.
5. Look beyond payer collections. High patient deductibles can create collection challenges even when claims are processed correctly.
6. Build continuity beyond discharge. Treatment organizations should consider how patients are supported after leaving a structured care setting.
7. Lead with a mission and a defined niche. Whether building or acquiring, founders need a clear reason for the organization to exist beyond expansion.
Listen to Episode 3 of The Cycle
John Peloquin's conversation offers a perspective shaped by decades of behavioral health operations. From the industry's move toward institutionalization to the practical realities of payer disputes, his experience highlights why operators need to rethink how they build and manage treatment organizations.
For RCM leaders, the message is especially clear: submitting claims is not enough. Providers need to understand their contracts, monitor payer performance, and be prepared to exercise their rights.
Watch Episode 3 on YouTube: Behavioral health deserves better, with John Peloquin
Also in this series:
- Episode 1: how Joe Henderson started Sierra Health and Wellness
- Episode 2: the acquisition playbook behind Sierra Health and Wellness
The Cycle is Supa's podcast featuring the founders and operators shaping behavioral healthcare, hosted by Samyukktha Thirumeni. Through candid conversations, the series explores the decisions, systems, and lessons behind building and running behavioral health organizations.
An offensive RCM strategy needs someone watching every contract clock at once, which is not work a person does well by hand. Book a demo to see how Supa tracks payment deadlines and denial follow-up.
RCM expert at Supa. 20+ years building revenue cycle operations in healthcare; Adjunct Professor at Concordia University-St. Paul teaching healthcare MBA.
Keep reading
All articlesBilling for Treatment Centers: In-House, Outsourced, or Automated?
How to Document the SUD Medicaid Work-Requirement Exemption
H.R. 1 and Medicaid: What Behavioral Health Billing Teams Need to Do Before 2027
Run this on your own practice.
Watch ambient agents handle your front desk, documentation, and billing — inside the tools you already use.



