How to Document the SUD Medicaid Work-Requirement Exemption
The two SUD pathways out of Medicaid's community engagement requirement, what the October 2026 ruling changed, and how to document each one.
In this article
- 1. What H.R. 1 says about SUD and Medicaid work requirements
- 2. The medically frail exclusion, as it stands after October 29, 2026
- 3. The treatment-program participation exclusion: A separate route for active participants
- 4. What documentation should an SUD treatment practice maintain?
- 5. How to write clinical documentation that supports a medical-frailty finding
- 6. ICD-10 codes can support identification, but they are not the complete exemption record
- 7. What happens when the state Medicaid agency requests documentation?
- 8. Part 2 confidentiality: Do not send SUD records without reviewing disclosure requirements
- 9. What changes before and after January 1, 2028?
- 10. A documentation checklist for SUD treatment practices
- 11. A sample provider documentation structure
- Frequently asked questions
- The bottom line: Document the right pathway, not just the diagnosis
H.R. 1 creates two separate pathways through which certain people with substance use disorders (SUDs) may be excluded from Medicaid's new community engagement requirement. For behavioral health and addiction treatment providers, understanding the difference is essential.
The first pathway is the medically frail or special medical needs exclusion. Congress listed substance use disorder as one of five subcategories of medical frailty. CMS's June 2026 rule added a second test - that the condition significantly impair the person's ability to meet the requirement - and a federal court vacated that test on October 29, 2026. The CMS rule's separate carve-out for people in stable recovery, defined as five or more years in recovery, was not challenged and remains in place.
The second pathway is the treatment-program participation exclusion. It applies to people participating in qualifying drug addiction or alcohol treatment and rehabilitation programs. This is a separate exclusion and does not require the same medical-frailty determination.
For SUD treatment practices, the practical question is what information can establish a patient's diagnosis, functional limitations, or current participation when the state Medicaid agency needs to verify an exclusion.
The answer depends on which pathway applies, the state's verification process, and the privacy protections governing the patient's records. A diagnosis code or admission record alone does not guarantee an exemption, because the state - not the provider - makes the determination.
This guide explains the two pathways as they stand after the October ruling, what clinical and administrative documentation can support them, how to prepare records for a state request, and how to protect patient information under 42 CFR Part 2.
It is one piece of a larger change. Supa's H.R. 1 and Medicaid guide covers the eligibility, renewal, and retroactive-coverage provisions that arrive on the same date.
Important: This is an operational documentation guide, not a legal interpretation or a substitute for state Medicaid instructions. Have compliance counsel and qualified clinical leadership review your procedures before implementation.
1. What H.R. 1 says about SUD and Medicaid work requirements
Section 71119 of H.R. 1 (Public Law 119-21) establishes a community engagement requirement for certain Medicaid applicants and beneficiaries.
Beginning no later than January 1, 2027, applicable individuals generally must demonstrate 80 hours per month of qualifying activities, or meet an alternative qualifying education or income pathway, to maintain or obtain coverage.
The requirement does not apply to everyone enrolled in Medicaid. It applies to a defined population, generally certain adults aged 19-64 enrolled in the ACA Medicaid expansion group or qualifying Section 1115 demonstration coverage.
The law also identifies specified excluded individuals who are not subject to the community engagement requirement.
Two of these exclusions are particularly relevant to SUD treatment providers:
| Exclusion | What it covers | What the provider may need to support |
|---|---|---|
| Medically frail or special medical needs | Individuals with an SUD, which Congress listed as one of five medical-frailty subcategories, subject to the CMS rule's stable-recovery limitation | Clinical evidence of the SUD and the patient's current status |
| Participation in a drug addiction or alcoholic treatment and rehabilitation program | Individuals participating in a qualifying treatment or rehabilitation program | Evidence of current participation and information establishing that the program meets the applicable definition |
These are separate legal pathways. A patient may potentially qualify under one or both, depending on their circumstances and the applicable state process.
The distinction matters because the evidence needed to support each pathway is different.
CMS implemented these provisions through its June 2026 interim final rule, published at 91 Fed. Reg. 33348 on June 3, 2026, which added requirements to 42 CFR 435.554 and 435.557. The rule in the Federal Register.
2. The medically frail exclusion, as it stands after October 29, 2026
The first pathway is based on medical frailty or special medical needs.
Congress defined that term by listing five subcategories, and substance use disorder is one of them. The other four are blindness or disability, a disabling mental disorder, a physical, intellectual, or developmental disability that significantly impairs one or more activities of daily living, and a serious or complex medical condition.
CMS's June 2026 rule, at 42 CFR 435.554(c)(5), added a second test on top of that list: the person's condition also had to "significantly impair the individual's ability to comply with the community engagement requirement."
Twenty-five states and the District of Columbia challenged that addition. On October 29, 2026, Judge Richard Stearns of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts held in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz that CMS "lacked authority to exclude any subset of individuals in the five subcategories delineated as 'medically frail' by Congress." He declared the impairment clause unlawful and vacated it under 5 U.S.C. 706(2), and separately enjoined CMS from applying it to the plaintiff states.
| What the court did | Scope |
|---|---|
| Vacated the "significantly impairs" clause in the medical-frailty definition | Removed from the rule under 5 U.S.C. 706(2) |
| Enjoined CMS from applying that clause | The 25 plaintiff states and D.C. |
| Barred CMS from penalizing plaintiff states for implementation errors or delays | Six months from October 29, 2026 |
| Upheld the 12-month lookback on claims and encounter data | Stands |
| Upheld the limit on repeated self-attestation | Stands |
| Left the January 1, 2027 deadline alone | Unchanged |
What this changes for documentation. The question is no longer whether a clinician can establish that the SUD stops the patient working. It is whether the record establishes that the patient falls within the statutory subcategory, and whether the CMS rule's stable-recovery carve-out applies to them.
That is a narrower documentation task, and in most charts it is already met. It is not, however, a reason to stop documenting function.
Why functional documentation is still worth keeping
Four reasons.
First, CMS expects states to maintain auditable and justifiable lists of qualifying conditions, and a state may still ask for information to establish that a patient falls within a subcategory.
Second, the injunction runs to the plaintiff states. A practice in a non-plaintiff state is relying on the vacatur alone, and HHS has not said whether it will appeal.
Third, several of the other exclusions and exceptions - and other Medicaid programs entirely - do turn on functional capacity.
Fourth, it is the clinical record. A chart that describes how a condition affects a patient's daily functioning is a better chart.
What a functional description covers
Where a clinician does document function, it should explain how the patient's condition affects their ability to work, participate in community service, or complete other activities.
Depending on the patient's clinical presentation, relevant functional effects may include:
- Difficulty maintaining consistent attendance or participation because of the condition.
- Impairment in concentration, planning, or task completion.
- Significant disruptions to daily functioning.
- Physical or psychological symptoms that interfere with sustained activity.
- Treatment-related functional limitations when supported by the patient's clinical circumstances.
- Co-occurring psychiatric or medical conditions that contribute to the impairment.
These are examples of areas a clinician may assess, not an official CMS checklist or automatic qualifying criteria.
The clinician must document the patient's actual presentation. A diagnosis should not be used to infer limitations that have not been assessed - and after the October ruling, there is no regulatory reason to reach for limitations the assessment does not support.
The stable-recovery limitation
CMS defines stable recovery for this SUD category as being in recovery for five or more years, at 42 CFR 435.554(c)(5)(i)(B). Its stated rationale is that the recurrence risk for someone in stable recovery is roughly that of the general population.
Individuals in stable recovery are excluded from the SUD category of the medically frail definition.
This carve-out was not challenged in Massachusetts v. Oz and remains in the rule. Worth noting, though: the court's reasoning was that CMS "lacked authority to exclude any subset of individuals in the five subcategories," which is a description of what the stable-recovery carve-out also does. It has simply not been litigated. Treat it as current law and watch for a challenge.
The distinction matters for documentation. A patient's historical SUD diagnosis does not automatically establish current medical frailty under this pathway.
The record should accurately reflect the patient's recovery history and current clinical status. Do not assume that a patient is in stable recovery simply because they are not currently receiving treatment, or that a patient in early recovery automatically meets the functional-impairment standard.
The state makes the final determination under its applicable process.
3. The treatment-program participation exclusion: A separate route for active participants
The second SUD-related pathway is based on participation in a qualifying drug addiction or alcoholic treatment and rehabilitation program.
This exclusion is implemented at 42 CFR 435.554(c)(8).
This pathway never turned on functional impairment, before or after the court ruling. It turns on a different question entirely: whether the individual is participating in a qualifying program.
That makes it the more administratively predictable of the two - and the one more likely to fail on a technicality, because the program itself has to qualify.
What qualifies as a treatment and rehabilitation program?
CMS uses the definition in Section 3(h) of the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008.
That definition covers a drug addiction or alcoholic treatment and rehabilitation program conducted by:
- A private nonprofit organization or institution; or
- A publicly operated community mental health center under Part B of Title XIX of the Public Health Service Act.
This has an important operational implication.
Not every organization that provides SUD treatment automatically qualifies as a program under this definition.
A provider's license, accreditation, treatment services, or participation in Medicaid does not by itself establish that the organization meets the federal definition.
CMS states that individual states will determine which rehabilitation and treatment programs meet the definition for purposes of the exclusion. Providers should therefore confirm their status with the relevant state Medicaid agency before relying on this pathway.
Is there a minimum number of treatment hours?
CMS has not established a federal minimum number of hours or days that an individual must participate in a qualifying program to meet this exclusion.
Instead, states may establish a minimum participation standard consistent with appropriate clinical guidelines.
This means the provider should not assume that:
- One admission automatically establishes eligibility for the entire year.
- A fixed number of treatment days applies nationwide.
- Every outpatient appointment qualifies as participation.
- Discharge automatically ends the exclusion on the same date in every state.
The state's definition and participation-verification procedure will determine what evidence is sufficient.
For documentation teams, the safest approach is to maintain accurate records of current participation and follow the state Medicaid agency's instructions.
4. What documentation should an SUD treatment practice maintain?
There is no single federal SUD exemption form or universal provider certificate prescribed by CMS for every state.
The documentation required will depend on the pathway, state implementation, and the information already available to the Medicaid agency.
However, treatment practices can prepare by maintaining two distinct documentation sets.
Documentation set A: Medical frailty based on SUD
For the medically frail pathway, the clinical record should support both the SUD diagnosis and the functional impact of the condition.
| Documentation element | What the record should establish |
|---|---|
| Clinical assessment | The patient's current clinical presentation and relevant SUD history |
| Diagnosis | The clinician's supported SUD diagnosis |
| Severity and course | Relevant symptoms, severity, duration, and clinical course |
| Functional assessment | How the condition affects the patient's ability to perform daily and community activities |
| Community engagement impact | How the condition affects the patient's ability to perform qualifying community engagement activities, where clinically present |
| Treatment history | Relevant treatment, services, and response to care |
| Current status | Whether the impairment remains present at the time of assessment |
| Clinician identification | Name, credentials, date, and signature of the qualified practitioner |
The most important part is the functional assessment.
A chart that only states "patient has opioid use disorder" may establish a diagnosis, but it does not necessarily describe how the condition affects the patient's ability to perform daily and community activities.
Documentation set B: Participation in a qualifying treatment program
For the treatment-program participation pathway, the record should support the patient's current participation and the program's status under the applicable state definition.
| Documentation element | What the record should establish |
|---|---|
| Program identity | Name and location of the treatment organization |
| Program qualification | Information confirming the program meets the applicable federal and state definition |
| Patient identity | Information matching the patient to the program record |
| Admission or enrollment date | When participation began |
| Current participation status | Whether the individual is currently participating |
| Services delivered | Relevant services and treatment activities |
| Attendance or engagement | Records supporting participation under the state's standard |
| Status changes | Transfers, interruptions, discharge, or completion |
| Authorized verification | Appropriate staff member or clinician confirming the information |
| Date of verification | When the participation information was last confirmed |
The state may require additional information or a particular certification format. Do not treat this list as a substitute for the state's requirements.
5. How to write clinical documentation that supports a medical-frailty finding
The strongest documentation establishes the condition clearly and describes its effects where they are present.
It should not be written simply to secure a Medicaid exemption. The clinician's role is to document the patient's actual clinical condition and its effects.
A useful structure includes four parts:
- Condition: What SUD or related condition has been clinically established?
- Current presentation: What symptoms, impairments, or complications are present?
- Functional effect: How do those clinical factors affect the patient's ability to perform relevant activities?
- Clinical basis: What assessment findings, observations, history, or treatment information support the conclusion?
Example: Insufficient versus more useful documentation
Thin documentation:
"Patient has opioid use disorder and is attending treatment."
This asserts a diagnosis without supporting it, and it says nothing about the patient's current status - which is what the stable-recovery provision turns on. It also conflates the two pathways in a single sentence.
More useful clinical documentation:
"The patient has a clinically established substance use disorder. Current assessment identifies [specific documented symptoms or impairments]. These findings affect the patient's ability to [specific functional activities]. The observed limitations are supported by [assessment findings, clinical history, or other relevant evidence]. The patient's current functional status and treatment needs will be reassessed as clinically indicated."
This is a documentation structure, not a statement to copy into every chart. Clinicians should replace the bracketed fields with patient-specific findings and should not include conclusions that are not supported by the assessment.
Avoid unsupported statements
The following phrases are too broad to establish the relevant functional relationship on their own:
- "Patient is in recovery." (Ambiguous in exactly the place the rule is specific: for how long?)
- "Patient cannot work." (A conclusion, and after the October ruling no longer the question.)
- "Patient is medically frail." (The state's determination, not the clinician's.)
- "Patient is receiving addiction treatment." (Which pathway, and at which program?)
- "Patient needs Medicaid to continue care." (True of most of the caseload, and not evidence.)
These statements may be relevant in context, but they do not replace the specific evidence the applicable pathway needs.
In particular, treatment participation should not be confused with medical frailty. They are separate exclusions with separate evidence, and a patient may qualify under one, both, or neither.
6. ICD-10 codes can support identification, but they are not the complete exemption record
SUD diagnosis codes are important for clinical documentation, billing, and identifying relevant records.
They may also help state Medicaid agencies identify patients who could qualify for the medical-frailty exclusion.
CMS expects states to maintain auditable and justifiable lists of qualifying conditions and may use diagnosis codes, claims, utilization, and other relevant information to identify potentially medically frail individuals.
However, a code is a label on a record, not the record. A state identifying a cohort from claims data is not the same as a state verifying that an individual falls within a statutory subcategory.
For example:
- An alcohol use disorder code documents a diagnosis. It says nothing about when the diagnosis was active, which is what the stable-recovery provision turns on.
- An opioid use disorder code may help identify a relevant clinical record, but a code on a claim from 2022 is not evidence of the patient's status in 2027.
- A historical SUD code does not establish current treatment-program participation, which is a separate pathway with separate evidence.
- A code associated with a co-occurring mental health condition may point at a different subcategory - a disabling mental disorder - rather than the SUD one.
The 12-month lookback the court upheld makes this concrete: a state verifying medical frailty from claims and encounter data may not look at data older than 12 months. A patient whose last coded SUD encounter falls outside that window will not be identified from data alone.
For coding references, see Supa's guides to substance use disorder ICD-10 codes, alcohol use disorder ICD-10 codes, opioid use disorder ICD-10 codes, and the stimulant, cannabis, and polysubstance code sets.
Why clinical and billing teams should coordinate
Clinical staff understand the patient's condition and functional limitations. Billing and eligibility staff understand payer requirements, state portals, and administrative verification processes - including what an eligibility check can and cannot establish.
Neither team should independently make the full exemption determination.
For mixed mental health and SUD caseloads, the companion question is which patients fall within the separate disabling mental disorder subcategory. Supa covers that in why a mental health diagnosis alone may not qualify.
A coordinated workflow helps ensure that:
- The diagnosis is supported by the clinical record.
- Functional limitations are documented by qualified clinicians.
- Participation records are accurate and current.
- The appropriate state process is followed.
- Protected records are disclosed only through an authorized route.
7. What happens when the state Medicaid agency requests documentation?
States must first attempt to verify specified excluded status using reliable information already available to them, where possible.
For medical frailty, this includes relevant adjudicated claims and encounter data from the preceding 12 months - a limit the October ruling specifically upheld.
For participation in a qualifying drug addiction or alcohol treatment and rehabilitation program, states must also attempt verification using adjudicated claims, payment data, encounter data, and other relevant information available to them.
This is important for providers: the state is not supposed to require patients to submit additional information when reliable information already available to the state can establish the exclusion.
However, there may be situations in which the state cannot verify the information through its existing systems. It may then request additional documentation or information.
A practical response workflow for treatment providers
When a patient or state agency requests supporting information:
Step 1: Identify the applicable pathway.
Determine whether the request concerns medical frailty based on SUD, participation in a qualifying treatment program, or another exclusion.
Step 2: Confirm the state requirement.
Review the current Medicaid agency instructions. Confirm the required form, acceptable practitioner credentials, documentation standard, submission method, and deadline. Whether the state has elected CMS's hold harmless period changes how urgent the answer is; Supa tracks that in which states are delaying H.R. 1 Medicaid work requirements.
Step 3: Identify the minimum necessary information.
Determine which records or statements are relevant to the specific verification request. Avoid sending a complete clinical record when a narrower document will meet the request.
Step 4: Obtain or confirm the necessary authorization.
Review applicable Part 2 consent requirements before disclosing protected SUD records.
Step 5: Prepare the supporting information.
Have the appropriate clinician or authorized program representative complete the requested documentation.
Step 6: Submit through the approved channel.
Use the state Medicaid agency's designated portal, secure process, or other approved submission route.
Step 7: Record the submission.
Maintain a record of what was submitted, when it was sent, who authorized the disclosure, and any response received.
Step 8: Follow up on the determination.
The state makes the eligibility decision. The provider should not mark the patient as exempt simply because supporting documentation was submitted.
8. Part 2 confidentiality: Do not send SUD records without reviewing disclosure requirements
This is one of the most important compliance considerations for SUD treatment practices.
Many federally assisted SUD programs are subject to the confidentiality requirements in 42 CFR Part 2. These rules protect certain records identifying a patient as having or receiving treatment for a substance use disorder.
A request from a state Medicaid agency does not automatically authorize unrestricted disclosure of Part 2 records.
On September 29, 2026, the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) issued guidance addressing the use of Part 2 records to verify exclusions from the Medicaid community engagement requirement.
The guidance describes circumstances in which a state Medicaid agency may use protected SUD records.
When can a state Medicaid agency use Part 2 records?
HHS identifies two relevant consent pathways.
1. Existing consent for future treatment, payment, and health care operations disclosures
A Part 2 program may have obtained a patient's written consent for all future uses and disclosures of records for treatment, payment, and health care operations purposes.
If that consent covers the disclosure, the program may disclose the relevant records to the state Medicaid agency for an appropriate purpose. The program must provide a copy of the consent or a clear explanation of its scope with the records, as required by Part 2.
The state Medicaid agency may then use the records for relevant treatment, payment, and health care operations activities, including verification of the exclusion, without obtaining an additional consent for that same permitted use.
2. Consent obtained by the state Medicaid agency
The state Medicaid agency may obtain written consent from the patient for the use of their Part 2 records to verify whether an exclusion applies.
The consent must meet the applicable requirements under 42 CFR 2.31, including the patient's right to revoke consent and an expiration date or event.
The precise disclosure and use must remain within the scope of the applicable consent and Part 2 rules.
What should SUD providers do?
Before sending records:
- Confirm whether the organization is a Part 2 program.
- Determine whether the requested records are protected Part 2 records.
- Review the patient's existing consent and its scope.
- Confirm whether the state has obtained a separate written consent.
- Provide the required consent documentation with the disclosure where applicable.
- Use the approved secure transmission method.
- Limit the disclosure to the information necessary for the stated purpose.
- Maintain a record of the disclosure.
Do not assume that a general HIPAA authorization automatically satisfies Part 2 requirements.
Also, do not assume that a state agency's request overrides Part 2 protections.
HHS's OCR guidance is particularly important because it explains how states can use SUD records for eligibility verification while maintaining the confidentiality protections that apply to those records.
Read the HHS OCR FAQ on Part 2 and Medicaid community engagement exclusions and OCR's announcement before establishing a records-disclosure workflow.
9. What changes before and after January 1, 2028?
CMS has established different verification rules for the initial implementation period and the period beginning January 1, 2028.
This matters because providers should not assume that a documentation process accepted during 2027 will remain sufficient indefinitely.
Medical frailty
Before January 1, 2028, when the state does not have reliable information or the available information is not reasonably compatible with information provided by or on behalf of the individual, the state may require documentation or accept a statement or other information under penalty of perjury that provides sufficient information to verify medical frailty.
Beginning January 1, 2028, the rules change. The state may accept a statement under penalty of perjury or other information in the specified circumstances for the initial verification during the beneficiary's enrollment period, subject to subsequent verification requirements.
At the first regularly scheduled redetermination after that status is established using the statement, the state must verify the status using reliable information or documentation if reliable information is insufficient.
After medical-frailty status has been verified, the state must reverify it at least every 12 months.
Treatment-program participation
For the treatment-program participation exclusion, the state must first attempt to verify current participation using available claims, payment, encounter, and other relevant information.
If reliable information is unavailable or incompatible with the information provided, the state must obtain sufficient information to verify current participation.
Beginning January 1, 2028, the state must require documentation when it is reasonably available. If documentation is not reasonably available, the state must have a process to accept other sufficient information.
These rules concern what the state must do when verifying exclusions. They do not establish a universal requirement for every SUD provider to submit a new certificate every six months.
Providers should monitor state implementation instructions and maintain current records that can support a verification request.
10. A documentation checklist for SUD treatment practices
Use the following checklist to review whether your clinical and administrative processes are ready.
Clinical documentation
- The patient's SUD diagnosis is supported by a clinical assessment.
- Current symptoms and relevant clinical history are documented.
- Functional limitations are recorded where clinically present.
- The relationship between the condition and ability to perform qualifying activities is addressed when medical frailty is being considered.
- Recovery history and current clinical status are accurately recorded.
- Documentation is signed and dated by the appropriate practitioner.
Treatment-program participation records
- The program's eligibility under the federal and state definition has been confirmed.
- Admission and participation dates are recorded.
- Current participation is documented.
- Services and attendance are recorded accurately.
- Transfers, interruptions, and discharge dates are updated.
- State-specific participation standards are followed.
Privacy and disclosure
- Part 2 applicability has been assessed.
- The patient's consent has been reviewed.
- The scope and purpose of disclosure are clear.
- Required consent documentation accompanies records where applicable.
- Only relevant information is disclosed.
- The disclosure and submission are documented.
Administrative coordination
- Staff know which state Medicaid agency to contact. Supa's state guides cover several of these systems: Optum Maryland, AHCCCS in Arizona, CMBHS in Texas, LME-MCO Tailored Plans in North Carolina, DMC-ODS in California, and NJMMIS in New Jersey.
- State-specific forms and submission instructions are available.
- Requests are assigned to a responsible staff member.
- Submission deadlines are tracked.
- The state determination is recorded separately from the provider's internal assessment.
11. A sample provider documentation structure
The following is a starting structure for a provider statement when the state requests supporting information. It is not a CMS form, a universal certification, or a substitute for a state-specific form.
The statement should be completed by a qualified practitioner or authorized program representative, depending on the pathway and state requirements.
Option A: Medical frailty based on SUD
Patient information
- Patient name:
- Medicaid member ID:
- Date of birth:
- State Medicaid program:
Clinical information
- SUD diagnosis:
- Date of assessment:
- Relevant current symptoms and clinical findings:
- Relevant treatment history:
- Current clinical status:
Functional impact
- Specific functional limitations documented:
- How the condition affects the patient's ability to perform qualifying community engagement activities:
- Clinical evidence supporting the functional assessment:
- Whether the impairment is current:
Practitioner information
- Practitioner name:
- Credentials and license:
- Organization:
- Contact information:
- Signature:
- Date:
Important: The clinician should only complete the functional-impact section when the findings support it. A diagnosis alone should not be used to certify medical frailty.
Option B: Participation in a qualifying treatment program
Patient information
- Patient name:
- Medicaid member ID:
- Date of birth:
- State Medicaid program:
Program information
- Program name:
- Program address:
- Organization type:
- State confirmation of program qualification, if available:
Participation information
- Admission or enrollment date:
- Current participation status:
- Services provided:
- Attendance or participation information relevant to the state's standard:
- Transfer, interruption, or discharge date, if applicable:
Authorized representative
- Name:
- Title:
- Contact information:
- Signature:
- Date:
Important: Do not use this statement until the state has confirmed that the program meets the applicable definition and the required participation standard.
Frequently asked questions
Does every person with an SUD qualify for a Medicaid work-requirement exemption?
No. There are two separate SUD-related exclusions. Congress listed substance use disorder as one of five medical-frailty subcategories, and a federal court vacated CMS's additional requirement that the condition significantly impair the person's ability to comply. The CMS rule still excludes people in stable recovery for five or more years from this SUD category. The separate treatment-program pathway applies to individuals participating in qualifying drug addiction or alcohol treatment and rehabilitation programs. In every case the state Medicaid agency decides.
Does a patient need to be actively receiving treatment to qualify under the SUD medical-frailty pathway?
The medical-frailty pathway is based on falling within a statutory subcategory, not on current treatment attendance - and after the October 29, 2026 ruling, not on proving functional impairment either. The separate treatment-program exclusion does require participation in a qualifying program. The patient's current status matters under the stable-recovery provision, as does the state's verification process.
Does participation in an outpatient SUD program automatically qualify a patient?
Not automatically. The program must meet the applicable federal definition, and the state determines which programs qualify. The state may also establish a minimum participation standard consistent with clinical guidelines.
Is there a federal minimum number of treatment hours required for the treatment-program exclusion?
No federal minimum number of hours or days has been established by CMS for this exclusion. States may establish a participation standard consistent with appropriate clinical guidelines.
Is an ICD-10 SUD diagnosis code enough to establish medical frailty?
No. A diagnosis code may help a state identify a relevant record, but it is not the verification. The state still has to establish that the individual falls within a statutory subcategory, and it may not use claims or encounter data older than 12 months to do it. Since the October 29, 2026 ruling, what the state may not require on top of that is proof that the condition impairs the person's ability to comply.
Can a treatment provider certify that a patient is exempt?
A qualified practitioner may provide clinical documentation or a statement when permitted by state rules and within their scope of practice. However, the state Medicaid agency makes the eligibility determination. Providers should not represent their own documentation as a final exemption approval.
What did the October 2026 court ruling change for SUD patients?
On October 29, 2026, a federal court vacated the part of CMS's rule requiring people in the five medical-frailty subcategories to also show that their condition significantly impairs their ability to comply with the community engagement requirement. Substance use disorder is one of those five subcategories. The ruling did not strike down the community engagement requirement, did not move the January 1, 2027 deadline, and did not touch the stable-recovery provision. Its injunction runs to the 25 plaintiff states and the District of Columbia; the vacatur removes the clause from the rule itself.
Can a state Medicaid agency request SUD treatment records?
The agency may use Part 2 records under the circumstances described in HHS OCR guidance, including applicable written consent pathways. Providers must review the scope of consent and comply with Part 2 before disclosing protected records.
Does the state have to request documentation from the patient before considering an exclusion?
No. States must first attempt to verify excluded status using reliable information available to them, where possible. If that information is unavailable or insufficient, the state must provide a process for obtaining the additional information needed.
Does the SUD exclusion guarantee continuous Medicaid coverage?
No. The exclusion concerns the community engagement requirement. It does not waive other Medicaid eligibility requirements, guarantee coverage, or prevent termination for unrelated reasons - including the six-month renewal cycle covered in Supa's guide to twice-yearly Medicaid redeterminations.
The bottom line: Document the right pathway, not just the diagnosis
H.R. 1 gives certain people with SUDs two distinct routes out of the Medicaid community engagement requirement: medical frailty, where substance use disorder is one of the five subcategories Congress named, and participation in a qualifying drug addiction or alcohol treatment and rehabilitation program.
For SUD treatment practices, the distinction determines what documentation is relevant.
Clinical teams should maintain accurate assessments and functional documentation. Program administrators should maintain evidence of current participation and confirm that the organization meets the applicable program definition. Billing and compliance teams should understand state verification procedures and protect Part 2 records when responding to requests.
Most importantly, providers should not promise patients that a diagnosis, treatment admission, or supporting letter guarantees an exemption. The state Medicaid agency makes the determination, and the legal position is still moving.
If responding to one state documentation request currently means three people searching three systems, the problem is retrieval rather than clinical. Book a demo to see how Supa keeps eligibility, authorization and documentation work visible in one place.
This article is for educational and operational purposes and is not legal advice. The litigation described here is ongoing and the exclusions turn on state implementation, individual circumstances, and Part 2 obligations specific to your organization. Have compliance counsel and qualified clinical leadership review your procedures, and confirm current requirements with your state Medicaid agency, before implementation.
The goal is to maintain accurate, current, and appropriately protected documentation so that patients who qualify can be identified and their exclusion can be verified without unnecessary administrative barriers.
RCM expert at Supa. 20+ years building revenue cycle operations in healthcare; Adjunct Professor at Concordia University-St. Paul teaching healthcare MBA.
Keep reading
All articlesBilling for Treatment Centers: In-House, Outsourced, or Automated?
H.R. 1 and Medicaid: What Behavioral Health Billing Teams Need to Do Before 2027
H.R. 1's Provider Tax and State-Directed Payment Limits: What to Watch
Run this on your own practice.
Watch ambient agents handle your front desk, documentation, and billing — inside the tools you already use.




