H.R. 1's Provider Tax and State-Directed Payment Limits: What to Watch
How H.R. 1 restricts Medicaid provider taxes and state-directed payments, and what behavioral health finance leaders should actually model.
In this article
H.R. 1 changes two important mechanisms states use to finance Medicaid: health care-related provider taxes and state-directed payments (SDPs). These changes could affect the funding behind certain Medicaid reimbursement arrangements, but they do not automatically reduce every behavioral health provider's reimbursement rate.
For practice owners and finance leaders, the key question is whether their state's behavioral health payment model depends on provider taxes, supplemental payments, or managed care arrangements that may be affected by the new federal limits.
This is the financing side of H.R. 1. The eligibility side - community engagement requirements, six-month renewals and shorter retroactive coverage - arrives on January 1, 2027 and is covered in Supa's H.R. 1 and Medicaid guide.
1. What is a Medicaid provider tax?
A provider tax is a state-imposed assessment on a class of healthcare providers. States use the revenue to help finance their share of Medicaid expenditures and draw down federal matching funds.
For example, a state may collect a tax from hospitals or another permissible provider class and use the revenue to support Medicaid spending for that class.
H.R. 1 Section 71115 (Public Law 119-21) restricts how states can use these taxes.
Beginning October 1, 2026, states generally cannot introduce new or increased provider taxes that exceed the applicable federal thresholds. The thresholds are tied to taxes enacted and imposed as of July 4, 2025.
For Medicaid expansion states, certain provider-tax thresholds will also be phased down beginning in federal fiscal year 2028:
| Federal fiscal year | Maximum phase-down threshold for applicable provider classes |
|---|---|
| 2028 | 5.5% |
| 2029 | 5.0% |
| 2030 | 4.5% |
| 2031 | 4.0% |
| 2032 onward | 3.5% |
These percentages are not universal caps on every provider's individual tax bill. They are the indirect hold harmless threshold, which applies to state-level calculations for applicable provider classes, and the actual threshold may be lower depending on the state's tax structure. Nursing facility and ICF/IID taxes are excluded from the phase-down.
CMS has separately proposed a rule amending the indirect hold harmless threshold (CMS-2452-P), posted on July 21, 2026, which is why the draft thresholds above should be read as the statutory schedule rather than a settled final rule.
The important financial implication is that states may have less flexibility to use provider-tax revenue to finance Medicaid payments over time.
CMS's October 19, 2026 communication to states makes clear that the new requirements already apply to fiscal years beginning on or after October 1, 2026, even though final implementing regulations remain pending. States are operating under an interim process while CMS develops final thresholds.
Source: CMS guidance on Section 71115 and provider taxes.
2. What are state-directed payments?
State-directed payments are arrangements through which states require Medicaid managed care plans to make specified payments to providers under their contracts.
They can be used to support particular provider categories, payment methodologies, or delivery-system initiatives.
For example, a state may require managed care plans to make additional payments to qualifying providers beyond their ordinary contracted reimbursement arrangements.
These payments can be an important source of revenue for healthcare organizations. Some states have used them to support hospitals, clinics, physicians, and other providers.
Section 71116 of H.R. 1 introduces new payment limits for certain SDPs, replacing the previous average commercial rate ceiling.
For the four service categories specified in the law, the total payment rate is generally limited to:
- 100% of Medicare payment rates in Medicaid expansion states.
- 110% of Medicare payment rates in non-expansion states.
The affected categories are inpatient hospital services, outpatient hospital services, nursing facility services, and qualified practitioner services at academic medical centers.
Certain existing arrangements may qualify for temporary grandfathering, with a transition and phase-down beginning with rating periods on or after January 1, 2028.
Source: CMS February 2, 2026 guidance on Section 71116.
One thing to watch when reading CMS's own materials: the Dear Colleague Letter on Section 71116 released on September 9, 2025 has been rescinded, and CMS's Working Families Tax Cut legislation page notes that. Check the date on any Section 71116 letter before relying on it.
3. Why behavioral health providers should pay attention
The statutory payment limits do not automatically apply to every standalone behavioral health clinic, therapy practice, SUD treatment facility, or CCBHC.
However, CMS's May 2026 proposed rule goes further than the four service categories specified in the law.
It proposes extending comparable payment limits to all services and state-directed payments, including payments to certain clinics, CCBHCs, and practitioners such as peer support specialists. The proposed effective date for these additional categories is the first rating period beginning on or after January 1, 2029.
That is the provision behavioral health finance leaders should be tracking. If a state funds CCBHC or peer support capacity through a directed payment, this proposal - not the statute - is what would reach it.
This is particularly relevant to behavioral health organizations that receive supplemental or directed payments through Medicaid managed care arrangements.
The distinction is important: the statutory limits are already relevant to the specified service categories, while the broader extension to additional behavioral health services remains a proposal as of November 14, 2026.
Source: CMS proposed rule CMS-2449-P.
4. Does this mean Medicaid reimbursement rates will fall?
Not automatically.
The impact depends on how a state currently finances Medicaid and whether a provider receives payments through an affected arrangement.
There are several possible outcomes:
- A state may reduce or restructure supplemental payment arrangements.
- A state may replace some provider-tax revenue with other funding sources.
- Managed care payment methodologies may change.
- A provider may experience changes in supplemental revenue while its underlying base fee schedule remains unchanged.
- Volume may shift as eligibility changes reach the caseload, which is a separate effect covered in Supa's guides to twice-yearly Medicaid redeterminations and documenting the SUD work-requirement exclusion.
- A state may redesign payment arrangements to comply with federal requirements.
The interaction between provider taxes and SDPs is particularly important. Provider-tax revenue is one source states use to finance the non-federal share of Medicaid payments. If that funding becomes more constrained, some state-directed payment arrangements may also face pressure.
However, the relationship is not one-to-one. A reduction in provider-tax revenue does not automatically translate into an equivalent reduction in an individual provider's reimbursement.
5. What should practice owners and finance teams monitor?
Individual practices cannot control state Medicaid financing policy. They can, however, understand their exposure.
Review the following:
| Financial area | What to examine |
|---|---|
| Base Medicaid rates | Current fee schedule and contracted reimbursement |
| Supplemental payments | Whether the organization receives additional payments beyond base rates |
| Managed care contracts | Whether payment arrangements include state-directed components - see Medicaid managed care |
| Provider taxes | Whether the organization belongs to a class subject to a state healthcare-related tax |
| CCBHC or special payment arrangements | Whether the organization participates in a payment methodology potentially affected by federal changes, including a behavioral health carve-out or a per diem rate |
| State budget updates | Whether the state has announced changes to Medicaid financing or reimbursement - Supa tracks the implementation picture in which states are delaying H.R. 1 Medicaid work requirements |
| Revenue concentration | How dependent the organization is on Medicaid and specific supplemental payment streams |
Finance leaders should also build a scenario model that separates base reimbursement from supplemental revenue. This makes it easier to understand the potential effect of a state payment change without assuming that every Medicaid rate will be reduced.
Supa's entries on payer mix and revenue integrity cover the reporting that makes this model possible, and the guide to revenue cycle management for behavioral health covers where the underlying numbers come from. For benchmarks to model against, see behavioral health billing benchmarks.
For practices operating across multiple states, review each state's financing arrangements separately. Supa has guides to several of these programs: Optum Maryland, AHCCCS in Arizona, CMBHS in Texas, LME-MCO Tailored Plans in North Carolina, DMC-ODS in California, and NJMMIS in New Jersey.
The takeaway
H.R. 1 changes the financing mechanisms behind Medicaid, not simply the rates printed on a provider fee schedule.
Provider-tax restrictions may constrain how states finance Medicaid, while state-directed payment limits may affect certain supplemental payment arrangements. The potential impact on behavioral health providers depends on the services they deliver, the payment structures they participate in, and the decisions their state makes.
For practice owners, the priority is to understand where Medicaid revenue comes from, distinguish base reimbursement from supplemental payments, and monitor state-specific changes before they affect financial projections.
If base and supplemental Medicaid revenue currently arrive in the same line of the same report, the first fix is visibility rather than policy. Book a demo to see how Supa reports Medicaid revenue by payer, program and payment type.
This article is for educational and operational purposes and is not legal, tax, or reimbursement advice. Provider-tax and state-directed payment rules depend on your state's financing structure, your organization's provider class, and rulemaking that remains in progress. Confirm current CMS guidance and state Medicaid agency instructions before relying on any of it for financial planning.
RCM expert at Supa. 20+ years building revenue cycle operations in healthcare; Adjunct Professor at Concordia University-St. Paul teaching healthcare MBA.
Keep reading
All articlesBilling for Treatment Centers: In-House, Outsourced, or Automated?
How to Document the SUD Medicaid Work-Requirement Exemption
H.R. 1 and Medicaid: What Behavioral Health Billing Teams Need to Do Before 2027
Run this on your own practice.
Watch ambient agents handle your front desk, documentation, and billing — inside the tools you already use.



